Goebel, S. & E. Weißenberger, B. Schmalenbach Bus Rev (2016) 17: 69. doi:10.1007/s41464-016-0005-8
Following recent corporate accounting scandals and governance failures, there has been a renewed interest in dysfunctional employee behaviors as potential drawbacks of financial goal-setting. Our study therefore assesses the impact of tight financial results controls as a cause for common behavioral displacements like information manipulation or gaming behavior in combination with countervailing effects of informal controls and management accountants’ business orientation as potential remedies. Based on a cross-sectional survey among 295 large- and medium-sized companies, our results show that even though a strong emphasis on financial results controls is associated with dysfunctional behaviors, higher levels of informal means of control and a more intense business orientation of management accountants are associated with a decrease of behavioral displacements. Our paper contributes to literature in a twofold way. First, it adds to the extant management accounting and control literature by providing comprehensive insights into the interplay between tight financial controls, informal controls, and management accountants’ role-taking behaviors. Second, by using a large-scale survey design, our results reflect a broad array of organizations and control situations.